What Is a Motion for Discovery?
A motion for discovery is a legal request to the court in a civil trial. The request asks the court to mandate that the opposing council and party turn over a given piece of material or information. It occurs during the pre-trial process in which each party prepares his or her case to present to the judge.
In the United States, when civil lawsuits are filed, each party is entitled to request certain evidence from the other side. This rule is in place because courts believe that often the person best capable of providing the evidence is the one being sued. For example, if an individual sues a company for fraud, it is most likely that the company will have documents that show the fraud occurred; as such, the plaintiff should be entitled access to those documents so he can prove the fraud he says exists does in fact exist.
As such, each party can file a discovery request of the opposing side. These requests must be tailored to the case at hand. In other words, any requests the party makes of the opposing side for information must be because he believes the request is likely to turn over something that can help him prove his case. When he files a motion for discovery requesting the court to compel the opposing side to turn over the information, he generally must specify what he is hoping to find within the documents or evidence and why he believes that evidence will be found.
A motion for discovery must also be reasonable. This means it must be narrowly tailored to the case and cannot be cost prohibitive. A plaintiff trying to prove fraud, for example, could request bank statements from a company during the period in which the alleged fraud occurred. He could not, however, request every financial document or email the company ever sent, as producing such information would likely be very costly for the company and would be unreasonable.
When a party makes a motion for discovery, the judge will consider the motion in light of the reasonableness and in light of the other party's opposing motions or requests, if any. Certain exceptions to discovery do exist, however. For example, privileged communication between clients and attorneys is not discoverable, and any motion or request for discovery of such information will generally be denied by a judge.
Why A Motion for Discovery Is Important for Your Case
The discovery process can help you build a stronger case. If you’re the defendant, it can also help you know what arguments the plaintiff is likely to make. That way, you can take steps to prepare counterarguments or gather additional evidence to defend yourself. Filing a motion for discovery can provide many benefits:
- Documents and other evidence to prove your case
- A clearer understanding of the facts of the case
- Witness testimony to back up your arguments
- A good estimation of the other party’s case
After seeing the evidence in your favor or against you, it’s easier to decide on your next steps. If you find strong evidence that supports your case, you may decide to move forward with a trial. If you see that the odds are stacked against you, you may decide to seek a settlement instead, saving time and money on court costs.
When Do You Need To Use a Motion for Discovery?
It’s not always necessary to use a motion for discovery when preparing for a trial. If the requested evidence is provided by the opposing side without problems, there’s no need for a judge to get involved. In many states, the discovery process legally requires both the prosecution and the defense to share relevant evidence, so court orders to obtain the evidence may not be needed.
If the other party’s law team or business refuses to hand over relevant evidence or provide testimony, then it’s necessary to involve a judge in the discovery process. A motion for discovery is a court document that orders a person, business or law firm to turn over the required documents or evidence. This type of motion can also compel witnesses to testify.
How To Write a Motion for Discovery
Different motion for discovery forms are used in every state. It’s wise to consult with a lawyer before writing a motion for discovery to ensure it covers local laws and meets court requirements. Here are some general things you need to provide:
- Your contact information: Provide your full name, address, phone number and email. You're the plaintiff if you’re filing the lawsuit or the defendant if someone is suing you.
- Other party’s contact information: Fill in the name, mailing address, phone number and email address of the opposing party.
- Situation leading to the motion to discovery: Explain in general terms what your case is about. This helps show the link to the evidence being requested. An example would be “victim of car accident that caused traumatic injuries,” for a personal injury case.
- List of items, evidence or information you’re seeking: Be specific when mentioning what evidence or testimony you require for your case. This evidence can include narrow groups of documents, such as all medical records related to a car accident in a certain range of time.
- Reason(s) you need the evidence: Show the connection between your case and the documents you're requesting. For example, the documents may be required to evaluate the truthfulness of injury claims.
- Reason(s) you believe the other party has the evidence: Explain why it’s reasonable to expect that the other person or business has the documents or can provide the testimony you want.
- Justification for your motion: Tell the judge why you were forced to seek a court order. Say if the other person has refused to turn over the evidence and why their excuses aren’t valid.
Usually, the last step is to sign and date the document. The motion of discovery generally contains an oath, so make sure all the statements you make are truthful before signing.
How Do I File a Motion for Discovery?
There are different rules and processes for filing motions in each state. In fact, counties and even individual judges may have unique rules you must follow. These rules are important because they can limit the amount of time you have for filing or set additional requirements for filing.
For example, sometimes motions for discovery must be filed jointly with the other party. It’s a good idea to check with a local law professional to avoid making any mistakes during this process.
Does a Motion for Discovery Require a Plea?
The timing of court trials can vary in state and federal cases, and it also depends on whether the trial is civil or criminal. In some cases, the prosecution isn’t legally required to turn over all evidence until just 10 days before the trial date.
In criminal proceedings, the plea is usually entered early, at the initial arraignment hearing. In any event, plea bargaining is generally possible even after a motion for discovery is filed because many prosecutors prefer to avoid the hassle of a trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Motion for Discovery?
In a legal case, a Motion for Discovery is a formal request made to the court by one party to obtain evidence from the other party. This is commonly used in civil cases and allows the requesting party to access various materials such as documents, physical evidence, and statements from witnesses that may support their arguments.
How does a Motion for Discovery work?
In legal proceedings, a Motion for Discovery asks the court to order the opposing party to reveal specific materials, such as documents, physical evidence, and witness statements that may help prove the requesting party's claims.
It's crucial to provide a detailed justification for why the requested evidence is relevant and essential to the case when submitting a motion for discovery. This will help the court understand the reasoning behind the request and make an informed decision on whether to grant or deny the motion. The court will then grant or deny the motion based on the merits of the request.
What types of evidence can be requested in a Motion for Discovery?
A Motion for Discovery can be filed to obtain different types of evidence relevant to a legal case. This may include written materials such as emails, contracts, financial records, and other documents that pertain to the case.
Additionally, tangible evidence such as photographs, videos, or recordings may be requested. Witness testimony, which can provide statements, opinions, or observations from individuals with knowledge of the case, is also often sought through this type of motion.
What is the process for filing a Motion for Discovery?
To initiate the process of filing a Motion for Discovery, the party requesting the evidence must prepare a written motion that comprehensively explains why the evidence is essential and relevant to the case. This written motion is the first step in seeking the court's permission to obtain documents, tangible evidence, or witness statements from the opposing party.
The motion must then be filed with the court and any supporting documents or evidence. After filing the written motion, the court will review it and determine whether or not to approve the request. If the court grants the Motion for Discovery, the opposing party must provide the requested evidence to the court.
What happens if the opposing party does not comply with the Motion for Discovery?
The court can dismiss the case or impose sanctions if the opposing party does not comply with the Motion for Discovery. These sanctions can include monetary fines, jail time, or other penalties. The court can even refer the matter to a criminal court in severe cases.
Before I grew up and got a real job, I was an attorney (I guess that makes me a recovering attorney these days -- kind of like an alcoholic in that you can never quite live it down). Anyway, I couldn't help but chuckle about the requirement that motions of discovery be "reasonable" because I saw a lot of very unreasonable requests filed.
If a plaintiff is suing a corporation with almost unlimited amounts of money at hand, it's a common practice for the defense lawyers to file motions asking for ridiculous amounts of documents as a way to harass and bully the opposition. It's a sleazy tactic which, sadly, is very effective.
Some reform in this area is desperately needed.
Post your comments